It’s very common that I’ve heard people tell me “you can’t just play the music on the page, you have to feel it.” At the surface level, it sounds a bit silly or like a lesson from a cheesy 1990s movie where a child learns about “the heart of music.” But when you play music, you know exactly what these people are saying.
Playing the sheet music exactly how it reads may produce an accurate presentation of the music, but it might feel emotionless. So much of music is affected by the personality of the musician.